Appreciating Cito Gaston
Since it is Cito Gaston Appreciation Day, I thought we should talk about what Cito does well. We point out things he doesn't do well quite often enough.
I got an email awhile back (one of those that is the internet equivalent of a letter written in crayon) complaining that Cito was "a proud black man". Now setting aside the racial insult, why shouldn't Cito be proud? Only 22 managers have ever won 2 World Series. Wouldn't you be proud? No mater what else goes on, and what us bloggers might say about him, he deserves to take pride in that.
Cito has the skill I most admire in a manager. He picks the players that he is going to run with and he stays with them. Fans get inpatient and are allowed to be inpatient. Brandon Morrow starts off the year poorly, he'll never be a pitcher. A player has a few bad at bats, fans want him out of the lineup. Cito understands that the way to win is to pick the players you think are your best options and use them. Don't let the emotions of the season cloud your judgement.
We saw how the opposite approach failed with John Gibbons and J.P. Riccardi. Frank Thomas starts the season slow, so we release him. Try Adam Lind, he has 19 bat at bats, send him away. Try Brad Wilkerson. Try Kevin Mench. Cito comes in and says Adam Lind is the guy and we are going to use him. Let's face it, if you start changing guys around like that, you aren't going to win anyway.
If Cito sees talent in someone he will stick with them. When we picked up Jose Bautista, he had a few poor at bats to start his Blue Jay career. Fans didn't like him. There was a Jose Bautista Facebook hate page up before he had 50 Blue Jay at bats but Cito is willing to trust his judgement.
Now we might complain that he stays too long with guys he likes, but he isn't going to win by changing his mind every few minutes anyway, so he's going to stay with his convictions.
Cito has a way of showing confidence in a player that must give the player a pretty good feeling. Back in the day, when the Jays picked up Devon White, Cito say 'he is my leadoff man'. Now Devon wasn't really what I'd want as a leadoff hitter and we had Roberto Alomar and, later, Paul Molitor who could have been great leadoff men, but Cito felt that by show confidence in White, it would make him a better player. And it did. Now there might have been gains by using a better leadoff batter, but they likely wouldn't equal the gains had by making White a better player.
Cito is a good hitting coach, he preaches the same approach all the time. He doesn't try to make things too complicated. He can look at a player's swing and make small suggestions that will help. He doesn't try to force major changes on players.
Cito has improved tremendously in how he handles starting pitchers. His first time round, as manager, he would leave guys in too long. He'd ride guys until their arms gave up. Now, think back this season, has he had a starter go too long? Very very rarely. He's been very careful with the young arms in his care. He deserves a lot of praise for that.
The pitchers in his bullpen have clear defined roles. I'm not that big a fan of that sort of thing but the pitchers know what their job is and they know when they do have a bad day Cito isn't over react.
He doesn't ask players to do things they can't. He doesn't force guys to bunt or to hit and run when they don't have the ability. Fans think these things come easy, but Cito knows they don't and doesn't put players in spots where they can't succeed. .
Cito doesn't try to make the game about himself. He isn't going to make moves to make you think he is a genius. He lets the players go out about win or lose the game. And let's face it, the players always do win or lose, no matter how smart the manager tries to look.
He doesn't go out to make a show of yelling at the umpire. He doesn't argue often, normally when he does he is controlled and states his point without getting too heated. He feels the team is better off with him on the bench than in the dressing room. When he does get a little heated it means more because it isn't an everyday thing.
He has a quiet class that rubs off on the rest of the team. We aren't like some of the other teams that complain over every call that doesn't go our way. Cito wouldn't allow it.
He seems to be a good guy. Someone that you would like to talk to. He has had an interesting life. Being a good guy might not be all that important a skill for a manager, but it is a great skill for a human being.
His teams have almost always been fun to watch. We have been treated to enough bad baseball, over the year, that good baseball is something that should be appreciated.
I don't always agree with Cito's moves but I do respect the man. I hope he can enjoy life away from the dugout and wish him the best.
22 comments
|
4 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Nice article
Cito did a lot of things well as well as puzzle (not much infuriate) me. He certainly knew his people and how to work with them.
I wish him well.
In honor of the Jays 2nd Baseman who played with fire in more ways than one.
by Damaso's Burnt Shirt on Sep 29, 2010 1:45 PM EDT reply actions
Cito did it his way...
And really when you know all managers are hired to be fired – that is the only SANE way to do it.
Things I admire about Cito:
Loyal to veterans – they’ve been there done it, he knows what they can do and not do, he is not scared by their peaks and valleys.
Loyal to guys like Buck and Overbay – AJ will have a 10 to 12 year career, he’ll have his chances – hopefully for him near his careers end someone will be on his side as Cito is now with Buck and the Big O.
This year with our young pitchers he NEVER panicked even came out at times to remind them he was going to let them “work their way through” the mess they were in. He also never let a young pitcher stay in past his sale by date.
Understands the season is a marathon and micro managing is just a cover for a manager who will never TRUST his players and who will always want to exclaim – “Ya but I went with the percentages.”
Cito is calm – seriously – almost scarily, unnervingly, otherworldly calm. A calm man in the midst of chaos. A rare trait.
Cito – I love ya! I think you are a GREAT manager – a great PERSON and the Jays have been blessed to have had your complete body of work with the team in all your roles. Bravo Sir – BRAVO!
Tom – well done you too – a great piece on Himself.
Cito's got a great eye for hitting
Throughout his career, but expecially recently, he has shown the ability to spot raw talent, and have faith in them and turn them into great hitters. Lind and Batista come to mind, but also Hill and Buck are also examples.
We know that when he spots good potential in a hitter, he sticks with them, no matter what the blogs, press, or heck, even the stats say. All of this has led me to a concearn I’ve had over the past few months.
Is there something with Snider that Cito has seen/not seen that has caused him to have a lack of faith in the young player.
Everyone (stat heads, press guys, scouts) before the season started would have told you that Snider had miles of more potential than Batista. Cito saw the opposite. It is clear he’s got a good eye for hitting.
Is there something with Snider that we arn’t seeing that Cito has?
There She Gooooooes!
He treated Shawn Green and Carlos Delgado the same...
I wouldn’t say that he thinks Snider won’t be good but that he thinks Snider should be brought along slow.
Only the best do I wish for Cito
I didn’t agree with all of his positions or decisions but on the whole I thought he did a great job in his second go-around with the Jays. I appreciate everything he’s done for the team and it’s genuinely hard to think of a nicer or classier individual.
"Let us go forth awhile, and get better air in our lungs. Let us leave our closed rooms... The game of ball is glorious." - Walt Whitman
by hugo on Sep 29, 2010 2:52 PM EDT reply actions 1 recs
and really
isn’t that all you can ask for?
Prehistoric Hoops - We're back! And we have a real domain!
Same
Im glad Cito is able to leave in grand fashion with a team that was supposed to lose 100 games and ends up over 500. Hes a great coach and although some of his decisions are a little iffy, I feel he deserves all the respect and courtesy from the fans as hes a great person and I hope its a packed house tonight to bid him farewell. I know I will definitely be there.
Very nice article
You’ve put into words many of the thoughts I’ve had about Cito.
While I’ve questioned certain aspects of how he manages the team from day-to-day, I’ve never questioned his class and his desire to win. Cito has left a tremendous legacy for the club and I hope that the new manager can build on the foundation that Cito has created.
I wish him the very best in the future.
Here here
Here here.
I wish Cito the best…until we see Brian Tallet in a 1 run ballgame tonight, than I’m going to go right back to cursing Cito’s name.
by craig in calgary on Sep 29, 2010 3:21 PM EDT reply actions
Healthy pitchers
The best thing Cito does is keep his pitching staff healthy. He doesn’t usually overuse pitchers and they are also used enough to keep up their arm strength. There haven’t been many pitching injuries either in his first term or this one. Just think where we would be this year if we had lost one of our top four starters to injury.
by JaysSaskatchewan on Sep 29, 2010 4:31 PM EDT reply actions
Watched game 6 of the '93 WS the other day
Here’s a weird compliment to Cito…he’s hardly aged a day since 93. If anything, he looks a bit leaner/fitter nowadays.
Well done Tom
I think this is the best “Cito Appreciation” article I have read , Too often we dwell on the negative. It is good to give the guy his due.
Nice words Tom
It’s nice to see everyone letting bygones be bygones and coming out with nice things to say about Cito as he winds down his managerial career. And Tom I think you’ve really captured here what makes him tick as a manager.
A couple of nice columns
All kinds of stuff being written about Cito at the moment, but here are a couple of columns.
Dave Perkins in the Star looks back at how Cito got the job by accident in a way. He loved his job as hitting coach, had to be convinced to take the managerial gig but only on an “interim” basis, then while no one thought he’d be the full-time candidate, it quietly became clear that he was the best for the job.
My favourite part of this story has always been Lou Pinella when interviewed for the job, telling Pat Gillick and company "you have the right guy there now" in Cito, which was a classy move on his part.
One interesting tidbit that was new to me in the column is Cito’s revelation that when he came back as hitting coach under Jim Fregosi and Buck Martinez, he realized that he didn’t really enjoy just being a coach anymore, but missed being manager:
"I still love to teach hitting. I still get my fingers in it a little every once in a while. When I came back to coach with (managers Jim) Fregosi and with Buck (Martinez), I really didn’t like coaching any more. I got used to (being a manager) and I wanted that again.
"What I learned is that as a coach you’re not sitting here worrying about what the hell is going on out there. You only worry about your hitters, or pitchers or bullpen or this and that. But as a manger you take care of everybody up and down the lineup. Everybody in this dugout, hitters and pitchers. And everybody else; the front office, the media, the players’ families, their wives and kids.
"The first time I realized that I was on the airplane, late one night, after I’d first started managing. I turned around and went, ‘Wow. I’m responsible for all these people on this plane.’ That’s the difference between coaching and managing.’’
The other column I liked is by Bob Elliott in the Sun. Already did a fanshot for it, but not sure how many people read those, so flagging it here again as it’s a nice read.
There’s all kinds of stuff about his early days in San Antonio and how he was signed that I didn’t know much of anything about. There’s also Cito’s picks for five best and worst moments of his career, along with his all time Jays team (of which a couple of picks kind of surprised me).
One other tidbit I liked from that Perkins column was that before agreeing to take on the manager’s job permanently in 1989, Cito first asked Paul Beeston and then chairman Peter Hardy (don’t know why Perkins refers to him as “Norman” – I always remember him as Peter) if he would be able to “take care of” his coaches:
"They asked me if I’d take the job and the first thing I asked was whether I could take care of my coaches. And they looked at me, like, ‘What’s wrong?’ I said I want to be able to take them out for dinner, take them for drinks. Because that’s the way Bobby Cox was with us (in the early 1980s). I never had a coaching staff as close as that coaching staff. There were only four of us, (pitching coach Al) Widmar, Jimy (Williams), (bullpen coach John) Sullivan and myself. We went everywhere together, with Bobby. That’s what I wanted, too.’’
That’s a classy move, be Cito and Cox before him. It’s the little things like that which build tight bonds and helps you get the best out of people. That was a nice group Cox had there, I have good memories of all those guys.
Cito...
I’ve steadfastly stuck up for Cito whenever he came under attack by the know-it-alls on these baseball blogs. My standard retort has been: “I imagine the Blue Jays pay Cito $2-million a year because he doesn’t know anything about baseball.”
No question Cito is the quintessential man’s man. He has earned the respect of his peers for his accomplishments over the years. I wish him all the best.
One hand/other hand
On the one hand, no other manager would have won a world series with any of the post-93 teams. And kudos to Gaston for guiding those two teams to WS victories.
On the other hand, he’s a poor in-game manager, no two ways about it.
Sorry.
you can argue that
but by ‘in-game’ you mean he’s bad at micromanaging. i would argue that his managing strength comes from ‘maximizing talent’ (as everyone says) and IN-GAME, he’s led the Jays to a .500 record. maybe some other managers would be better (and more prone to) pinch-hit and use relievers better, but there is no manager in the world who behaves like baseball blogs want him to.
Prehistoric Hoops - We're back! And we have a real domain!
Wonderful Article
The word “skipper” is used for baseball managers and ship’s captains. While many baseball managers are prone to micro-managing Cito is more like the ship’s captain, maintaining the steady course and not panicking in the moment. His confidence inspires confidence in his players.
I’ll miss him.
by bluejaysstatsgeek on Sep 30, 2010 1:47 PM EDT reply actions
Good analogy
I like your analogy of baseball managers being like ship’s captains who’s main job is just keeping a steady hand on the wheel. Cito was a good skipper in that respect.

by 





















