Results:

Deck McGuire - 43.5% (54%)

Justin Nicolino - 43.5% (45%)

Aaron Sanchez - 5%

Daniel Norris - 7.25%

Adonys Cardona - 0.75%

Nominations:

Kevin Comer - 6

Asher Wojciechowski -3

John Stilson - 3

Chad Jenkins - 9

Joel Carreno - 3

Mitchell Taylor - 2

Joe Musgrove - 0

List:

#1. Drew Hutchison - 50%

#2. Noah Syndergaard - 33.3%

#3. Nestor Molina - 41%

#4. Deck McGuire - 43.5% (54%)

Players classified as rookies in 2011 will not be considered

Poll closes Friday October 7, 10 PM Eastern