The Jays should aggressively go after Emilio Bonifacio - he has a high on-base percentage and was among the league leaders in stolen bases....he would serve as a very strong lead-off hitter. I don't know about his defense, but if it's good, then he should be aggressively sought after. We would only have him for 3-4 years, but Hechavaria will be an option before then.
Then move Kelly Johnson or make him your left fielder for 2012.
Top of the order:
Bonifacio OBP 360
Excobar OBP 369
Baustista OBP 457