We Still Haven't Walked in the Glow of Each Other's Majestic Presence: xFIP-based Pitcher WAR Rankings Update

Hey all, just a quick update on xFIP-based WAR (as explained, here) for any interested parties.  Check them after the jump.  A quick methods update, I have included park effects by determining the difference between my estimated FIP-based WAR and fangraphs actual WAR and then adding it to xFIP-based WAR.  Roy Halladay is still on top.  Jays pitchers (Ricky RomeroBrandon Morrow, and Jo-jo Reyes) in black and bold.

Name IP FIP fWAR xFIP pkadj xWAR
Roy Halladay 143.1 2.16 5.1 2.45 4.53
Justin Verlander 157 2.7 4.7 2.96 4.17
CC Sabathia 153.2 2.48 5.1 3.1 3.87
James Shields 148.2 3.17 3.2 2.92 3.65
Clayton Kershaw 137.2 2.51 4 2.7 3.64
Cliff Lee 137.1 2.78 3.6 2.76 3.64
Cole Hamels 136.1 2.59 4 2.85 3.51
Felix Hernandez 151.2 2.97 3.6 3.03 3.49
Dan Haren 140.2 2.62 4.2 3.11 3.33
David Price 135 3.11 3 2.95 3.26
Tim Lincecum 129.1 2.7 3.5 2.94 3.07
C.J. Wilson 139 3.14 3.4 3.37 3.01
Jhoulys Chacin 123 4.22 1.5 3.48 2.75
Jered Weaver 147 2.43 4.8 3.54 2.69
Matt Garza 102 2.92 2.7 2.96 2.64
Ryan Dempster 119.1 3.71 2 3.32 2.64
Anibal Sanchez 119.1 3.27 2.4 3.13 2.63
Ian Kennedy 135.1 3.61 2.4 3.54 2.53
Edwin Jackson 115.2 3.17 2.8 3.4 2.48
Ricky Nolasco 133.1 3.17 2.8 3.37 2.43
Tommy Hanson 108.2 3.11 2.3 3.03 2.42
Madison Bumgarner 110.2 2.46 3.4 3.11 2.42
Jaime Garcia 117.1 2.99 2.6 3.13 2.38
Jon Lester 114.1 3.94 1.7 3.46 2.33
Justin Masterson 128.2 2.99 3.2 3.55 2.3
Chris Carpenter 136.2 3.22 2.6 3.41 2.25
Daniel Hudson 125 2.92 3.3 3.55 2.22
Ervin Santana 131.1 3.88 1.8 3.62 2.2
Ricky Romero 127.1 3.87 1.8 3.63 2.16
Ubaldo Jimenez 110.1 3.42 2.4 3.59 2.14
Brandon Morrow 94.2 2.66 2.8 3.25 2.1
Tim Hudson 120.1 3.32 2.2 3.39 2.08
Jon Niese 118.1 3.31 2.1 3.32 2.08
Trevor Cahill 134 3.95 1.6 3.66 2.06
Scott Baker 110.2 3.42 2.1 3.47 2.03
Yovani Gallardo 121.1 3.83 1.4 3.48 1.98
Josh Beckett 111 3.17 2.7 3.71 1.96
Matt Cain 126.1 2.93 3 3.53 1.96
Bud Norris 117.2 3.7 1.5 3.42 1.95
Michael Pineda 113 3.18 2.4 3.51 1.94
Derek Holland 118.2 4.06 1.6 3.86 1.87
Gavin Floyd 119.1 3.89 1.8 3.84 1.87
Alexi Ogando 104.2 3.52 2.1 3.71 1.86
Tim Stauffer 118 3.29 1.8 3.26 1.85
Max Scherzer 119.1 4.16 1.4 3.86 1.83
A.J. Burnett 119.1 4.55 0.9 3.86 1.82
Gio Gonzalez 113 3.58 1.8 3.57 1.81
Derek Lowe 113 3.45 1.8 3.45 1.8
Shaun Marcum 111.2 3.56 1.7 3.52 1.76
Mark Buehrle 121 3.87 2 4.06 1.72
Colby Lewis 121.2 4.7 0.8 4.04 1.7
Hiroki Kuroda 120.2 3.72 1.5 3.6 1.7
Chris Volstad 103.1 4.59 0.4 3.68 1.69
Doug Fister 133 3.16 2.8 3.86 1.67
Carlos Carrasco 108 3.85 1.5 3.74 1.64
Jeff Francis 122.2 3.9 1.8 4.02 1.63
Jordan Zimmermann 115 2.59 3.3 3.65 1.63
Bronson Arroyo 114.2 5.46 -0.5 4.11 1.61
Zach Britton 104.1 3.98 1.5 3.89 1.61
Chris Narveson 108.1 3.5 1.7 3.58 1.58
Josh Tomlin 120.2 4.22 1.1 3.86 1.58
Luke Hochevar 125.2 4.7 0.8 4.2 1.55
Mike Leake 94.2 3.97 1.1 3.64 1.53
Philip Humber 107.1 3.5 2.2 4.03 1.51
Brett Myers 126 4.88 -0.1 3.96 1.49
Chad Billingsley 116.1 3.42 1.9 3.69 1.47
Nick Blackburn 117.1 4.53 0.7 3.98 1.41
Matt Harrison 103.2 4.05 1.4 4.06 1.39
Carl Pavano 130 3.97 1.6 4.12 1.38
Jeff Karstens 107.2 4.49 0.4 3.83 1.37
John Danks 94 4.16 1.2 4.02 1.35
Jeremy Guthrie 123.1 4.35 1.2 4.25 1.35
Wandy Rodriguez 102.1 4.1 0.8 3.71 1.35
R.A. Dickey 121.2 4.13 0.9 3.88 1.32
Chris Capuano 102.2 3.94 1 3.72 1.31
Joe Saunders 118 4.88 0.4 4.32 1.31
Jair Jurrjens 110.2 3.11 2.3 3.77 1.3
Kyle Lohse 122 3.69 1.6 3.88 1.28
Charlie Morton 97 3.46 1.6 3.72 1.25
Jason Marquis 106.2 3.88 1.3 3.92 1.24
Jason Vargas 127.1 3.85 1.6 4.11 1.21
Paul Maholm 126.2 3.74 1.7 4.03 1.2
Carlos Zambrano 116.2 4.06 1.4 4.2 1.18
Fausto Carmona 104.1 4.8 0.3 4 1.17
Brian Duensing 102.1 3.7 1.6 4.09 1.14
Livan Hernandez 125.1 3.72 1.7 4.05 1.13
Rick Porcello 96 4.15 1.1 4.16 1.09
Ted Lilly 107 4.6 0.2 4 1.08
Freddy Garcia 97 3.94 1.4 4.23 1.07
Jake Arrieta 102.1 5.09 0.2 4.38 1.05
John Lannan 114.1 4.11 1 4.09 1.03
Ivan Nova 91.2 4.44 0.8 4.23 1.02
Jake Westbrook 102.2 4.57 0.2 3.99 1.01
Jason Hammel 110.2 4.58 0.9 4.53 0.98
Kevin Correia 116.2 4.12 1 4.14 0.97
Brad Penny 110 4.45 0.9 4.46 0.89
Mat Latos 100.1 3.44 1.3 3.79 0.82
Javier Vazquez 103.1 4.37 0.7 4.29 0.81
Randy Wolf 118.1 4.41 0.6 4.32 0.75
Kyle McClellan 97.2 4.73 0 4.19 0.72
Jo-Jo Reyes 105.2 4.55 0.7 4.57 0.68
Jeremy Hellickson 103.2 4.32 0.8 4.48 0.61
James McDonald 97.2 4.73 0.2 4.51 0.49
Mike Pelfrey 112.2 4.62 0.2 4.44 0.48
Dustin Moseley 107 4 0.6 4.1 0.45
J.A. Happ 100 4.54 0.3 4.47 0.4
Tyler Chatwood 99.1 4.39 0.8 4.82 0.29
Clayton Richard 99.2 4.15 0.4 4.34 0.14
Wade Davis 103.2 4.93 0.1 5.15 -0.18

In This Article

Teams
Players
X
Log In Sign Up

forgot?
Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

Join Bluebird Banter

You must be a member of Bluebird Banter to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Bluebird Banter. You should read them.

Join Bluebird Banter

You must be a member of Bluebird Banter to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Bluebird Banter. You should read them.

Spinner.vc97ec6e

Authenticating

Great!

Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.

tracking_pixel_9351_tracker