Given that the Jays can probably only sign one of these players who would you prefer?
Albert Pujols - 31 Years old (32 in January) - averaged 7.1 WAR over the past 3 seasons (excluding the remainder of this season). His 2011 WAR so far is 4.9 . He seems older but he is only 9 months older than Bautista.
Prince Fielder - 27 Years old - Averaged 4.7 WAR over the past 3 seasons (once again excluding the remainder of this year). His 2011 WAR so far is 4.3 .
Yu Darvish - Is 25 years old.
You can assume all the signings would be at fair market value, whatever that is.
I think I would take Pujols but it depends on $. Any of them would be exciting :)