clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Edwin Encarnacion Does Not Win Silver Slugger Award

Blue Jays DH Edwin Encarnacion does not win a Silver Slugger Award for his fantastic 2012 season. The Kansas City Royals' Billy Butler receives the honour.


Toronto Blue Jays designated hitter Edwin Encarnacion was the favourite coming into today to win his first Silver Slugger Award today. The award, which is appropriately a silver-plated Louisville Slugger bat replica, is granted to the best offensive player at each position in each league. Encarnacion was the best offensive designated hitter in the American League in 2012.

However, Major League coaches and managers decided to award the Silver Slugger to Kansas City Royals DH Billy Butler. Butler had a great season, hitting .313/.373/.510 with an OPS+ and wRC+ of 140, hitting 29 homers and 107 runs batted in. He accumulated 3.2 WAR in 138 games at DH and 20 games at 1B. He was selected to the All-Star Game, and was greeted loudly by his hometown crowd. Congratulations Billy! Even though I think Encarnacion was a better choice for the honour, Butler had a tremendous season as well.

Encarnacion had a breakout year in 2012, hitting .280/.384/.557 while hitting a career-high 42 home runs and driving in 110 runs. His OPS+ and wRC+ were 152, and he was worth 4.4 fWAR and 4.6 brWAR as a designated hitter. His plate discipline improved, swinging at just 21% of balls outside the strike zone, 9 percentage points better than his rate in 2010, leading to an increased walk rate.

He was in a tight race for the American League Home Run King title with Miguel Cabrera (44 HR, 697 PA), Josh Hamilton (43 HR, 636 PA), Curtis Granderson (43 HR, 684 PA), and Adam Dunn (41, 649 PA), ultimately finishing fourth in the league with 42 HR in 644 PA. His injuries down the stretch slowed him down in the race.

All across the board, except for batting average, Edwin Encarnacion had recorded better numbers than Billy Butler. However, Edwin played just 82 games at DH, spending 68 games at 1B, three at LF and one at 3B. The position split has been cited as why the position-based award went to Butler. But in 2002, Manny Ramirez won the DH Silver Slugger while DHing 51 games and playing in the outfield for 68 games, and more recently, in 2008, Aubrey Huff won as a designated hitter while DHing 98 games and playing 57 games on the field.

This should, of course, not tarnish Encarnacion's tremendous season. He carried the Blue Jays offense after Jose Bautista went down with injuries. He started off the season in the 5th spot in the lineup before his solid play forced manager John Farrell to declare him the club's cleanup hitter in early May, and later was bumped up to third when Bautista was on the disabled list. His smile, which appeared much more often this year, would light up the dugout.

Encarnacion was awarded by the Blue Jays in mid-July when he signed a 3-year, $29 million contract extension, which includes a $10 million club option for 2016. I guess that's the more important award.


Jose Bautista receiving his 2011 Silver Slugger Award. Let's hope we see Edwin standing together with Jose in 2014 to receive their 2013 Silver Sluggers. Photo Credit: Tom Szczerbowski-US PRESSWIRE

This is the first season since 2008 that the Blue Jays would not have a Silver Slugger winner: Aaron Hill (2B) and Adam Lind (DH) both won in 2009, and Jose Bautista (OF) won it in both 2010 and 2011.

Prior to that, Blue Jays winners included: Damaso Garcia (2B, 1982), George Bell (OF, 1985, 1986, 1987), Jesse Barfield (OF, 1986), Lloyd Moseby (OF, 1983), Fred McGriff (1B, 1989), Kelly Gruber (3B, 1990), Joe Carter (OF, 1991, 1992), Roberto Alomar (2B, 1992), Dave Winfield (DH, 1992), Paul Molitor (DH, 1993), Jose Canseco (DH, 1998), Carlos Delgado (1B, 1999, 2000, 2003), Shawn Green (OF, 1999), and Vernon Wells (OF, 2003).

Unfortunately, Edwin Encarnacion will have to wait one more year to see his name join that list. For the heck of it, let's see him t-rexing one more time:


via NotGraphs