clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Hall of Fame Poll: Mark McGwire

New, 16 comments

Would you vote Mark McGwire into the Baseball Hall of Fame?

Mark
Mark
Harry How/Getty Images

This is Mark McGwire's 10th time on the Hall of Fame ballot. In his first years, he was running at about 23%, last year he hit a low point of 10%

McGwire's numbers are well known: 583 home runs, 1414 RBI, 1317 walks, a 263/.394/.588 line. AL Rookie of the Year in 1987. 12 All-Star teams. 1 Gold Glove. 3 Silver sluggers. Amazingly enough, no MVP awards.

He is number 8 on the career list in Slugging Average. Number 10 in home runs. 67th in RBI. 62.0 career WAR puts him 106nd all time among position players. He is credited with helping to save baseball after the strike.

And there was some other stuff. What was it? Oh yeah, Steroids. Considering how important he was to the game, after the lockout, and how the very writers that are voting were the ones that turned a blind eye to what he was doing, you would think they would have more sympathy.

And there was the famous 'I'm not here to talk about the past', when asked by congress about it. Gotta wonder what he thought he was there about. What he should have said was: Do you want to know the terrifying truth, or do you want to see me sock a few dingers?

My usual view of PEDs is that if I think the player would have had Hall of Fame numbers without using, I think he should go in. McGwire, if he wasn't using I don't think he would have numbers that would get him in.

He worked as hitting coach with the Dodgers since 2013 and before that he was in the same role as for the Cardinals.