clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Hall of Fame Poll: Scott Rolen

Would you vote Scott Rolen into the Baseball Hall of Fame?

Toronto Blue Jays v New York Yankees Photo by Jim McIsaac/Getty Images

Next on our list is former Blue Jays third baseman Scott Rolen.

It is Scott’s second time on the ballot. He only got 10.2% of the Writers’ vote last year. He’s one of those who doesn’t have that one great stat that Writers can look at and say ‘he should be in’, but then he was good at all parts of the game. Bobby Grich is a good comparable in that way. Grich should be in the Hall, but the Writers have a hard time with guys who do everything well.

Scott played 17 seasons in the MLB, 7 with the Phillies, 6 with the Cardinals, 4 with the Reds and, most important, 2 with the Jays.

He hit .281/.364/.490 with 316 home runs in 2038 games. He was Rookie of the Year in 1997, won 7 Gold Gloves, made 7 All-Star teams, and received MVP votes 4 times. And, for a brief period, he was the GOAT. He had a stretch of 7 straight season with 25 or more home runs.

He was a favorite in his short time with the Jays. He was really great on defense. It helped that he started his Jays career with a 7 game hitting streak. He came to us in trade for Troy Glaus. And he left us for Edwin Encarnacion, Josh Roenicke and Zach Stewart. Edwin was a throw in and we are lucky he was thrown in.

His bWAR was 70.2 (fWAR 70.1), which putting him 67 all-time among position players.

I was just looking at Brooks Robinson’s career, Rolen looks like a better version of Brooks, so I’ll vote yes. Of course, they played in different eras.

You can see Scott’s stats here. For comparison, Brooks Robinson is here.

Matt’s chart:


Most similar careers: Larry Walker (on ballot), Bobby Grich, Johnny Bench (elected BBWAA), Reggie Smith, Jim Edmonds, Gary Carter (BBWAA), Duke Snider (BBWAA), Yogi Berra (BBWAA). The tricky thing for Rolen is most of the comparable players elected were catchers.


Would you vote Scott Rolen into the Baseball Hall of Fame?

This poll is closed

  • 58%
    (171 votes)
  • 41%
    (120 votes)
291 votes total Vote Now