clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Question Time: Which Blue Jays player turned out to be much better than you ever expected?

If you buy something from an SB Nation link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

New York Yankees v Toronto Blue Jays Photo by Vaughn Ridley/Getty Images

There isn’t much for Blue Jays news this morning, though, with my luck as soon as I hit publish something will happen.

There is a nice story on Devon Travis by John Lott. I’m always going to be a fan of Devon, I hope something works out for him.

And, though he wasn’t a Blue Jay, it is Luis Tiant’s birthday and Tiant was one of those guys who helped make me a baseball fan. Why? Well, who wouldn’t be a fan of a pitcher whose windup looked like this:

I have a Tiant signed ball up on my mantle.

Happy 79th birthday Luis. I hope you enjoy a cigar tonight.

So I thought I’d ask a question: Which player in Blue Jays history for whom you had little in expectations, out performed your hopes the most?

The obvious answer, to me, is Jose Bautista, we figured he was a platoon player, he could hit lefties, but shouldn’t be out there against right-handers, but he turned into Jose Bautista. I remember the ‘we hate Jose Bautista’ facebook page, so I wasn’t the only one that didn’t see his potential.

An aside, Jose is apparently looking for a job.

Putting Bautista aside, I’d go with Marco Scutaro. When we traded for him, I thought he was roughly a replacement player, a little better with the bat than John McDonald, and not as good with the glove, but not much more than that. We had Aaron Hill and David Eckstein, so Scutaro looked like a bench guy.

Eckstein turned out to be pretty bad, then his biggest hit of the season was an elbow to Hill’s head, putting Aaron out of the lineup and Scutaro into it.

Marco turned out to be great. He put up a 2.9 fWAR in 2008 and a 4.2 fWAR in 2009, did a great job in the leadoff spot. And he was a lot of fun to watch. His teammates seemed to like him. And he was a very ‘heads up’ player:

If you want to back a little ways, Rance Mulliniks came over in trade from the Royals after spending 3 years with the Angels and two years with the Royals, a playing as weak hitting shortstop (he had a career .232/.288/.309 batting line). Who figured he could be a very good platoon third baseman? Well, Bobby Cox figured he could. And, then new, hitting coach Cito Gaston worked with him. He learned to pull the ball, and, being a smart player, he learned out to control the strikezone.

He spent 11 seasons with the Jays, hitting .280/.365/.424. In his 6 year prime he his .293/.374/.458. And he played very good defense at third. He looked like an accountant, but he was smart and he figured out how to get the most out of his ability.

So give us your choice of the Blue Jays player that exceeded your expectations the most?