Hall of Fame Polls: Mark Buehrle

Mark Buehrle is one of the most challenging choices on the list..

Mark was never the best pitcher in the game. He received Cy Young votes just once, finishing 6th in 2005, though he likely deserved votes in other seasons. He only made 5 All-Star teams. He never won 20 games (got 19 once). Most seasons he finished between 13 and 16 wins.

On the other side, he was incredibly consistent. He started more than 30 games in 15 of his 16 MLB seasons. He had the streak of 14 seasons with 200 innings pitch (and come up just 1.1 innings short of making it 15 seasons). We won’t see that again for, at least, a very very long time (even before 2020 was a shortened season, it was unlikely to happen).

His career 214-160 record puts him number 91 on the all-time list in wins. He’s 65th in bWAR for pitchers. He didn’t walk many, just 2.0 per 9 innings career.

Mark only had 1 losing season. He was 12-13 in 2006. I know it doesn’t mean all that much, but to be consistently on the winning side, even on some not so great teams, is a positive to me.

When he came to the Blue Jays, Cee Angi told us, in a guest post, that we would love Mark Buehrle, and she was right. It took a bit. He has a plodding start with the Jays but turned it around after a particularly crappy start against the Rays. He gave up 7 runs in the third inning (including two home runs). Amazingly, John Gibbons left him in the game. He finished out 6 innings, giving up 9 hits and the 7 earned. That turned out to be a turning point. He lowered his season ERA every start for his next 21.

I wrote that he taught me about pitching:

I’ve always thought that pitchers should be convinced that they are throwing the right pitch before they start their wind up. Buehrle would rather throw the wrong pitch and keep himself in his rhythm. Keeping in rhythm is the most important thing to Mark.

He also kind of just throws and uses his defense. That’s not quite a fair way of saying it, but he tries for contact, preferably soft contact, and he figures, most times, the ball will find a glove.

Continuing:

When he’s going good, he is a joy to watch. Innings go by quickly, he doesn’t walk anyone (less than 2 per 9 innings as a Jay). He pitches to the edges of the strike zone but rarely off the edge. He gets by with movement, changing speeds....mostly from slow to slower. He gives us the feeling that we could be pitchers if we learned to hit our spots.

He’s kind of Batman, not Superman, we think we could work hard enough to be him. We all know we can’t throw 100 mph, but we all think we could hit high 70’s (with work), and if we had learned to hit those spots, we could be him. We know we can’t throw as hard as Marcus Stroman, but we think (wrongly) that we could have been Buehrle if we worked enough.

With the Jays, he took the role of the elder statesman. He was great with Marcus Stroman in particular.

One more bit I wrote:

I also like that he didn’t wear goggles for the Jays celebration, preferring to let the champagne sting his eyes. For some reason, that seems far more zen to me. Why spray it around if you don’t want to feel it when it hits you.

I think it will be more challenging for the Writers to make their Hall of Fame votes, on pitchers, in the future. The line always seemed to be 300 wins, something that we aren’t going to seeing in the future. 200 wins will be a tough line to cross.

I very much hope that Buehrle clears the 5% hurdle to stay on the ballot (but then I thought that Carlos Delgado would easily get 5% of the vote in his first time on the ballot). I think Mark is a player that will need time for the writers to talk about, think about before they can fairly judge him.